General Forum

Guys and girls,

2018 topps platinum michael fulmer 1/1.  I have an offer for $80 on ebay.  In two days i have over 70 views and 6 people watching it.  Should i take the offer? I have starting bid at $99.99  I trust your knowledge and cantor.  

Only up for 2 days? I'd be greedy. Heck, it's the only one - you call the shots. :)

But, I would counter with the price I really want to see - they're already 20% lower than your original price. Maybe counter with $95 (or make it $95 with shipping if you're not offering free shipping).

I certainly wouldn't let it go at $80 (unless it was a TCDB member, then I would).

I would hang on you have a few days to accept decline the offer ect and see what happens. People will always say take it down i will pay this much or take this offer ect. 

If it dont sell relist it till you get what you want.

That many views and 6 people watching thou i reckon someone will bid.. 

Or you could just give it to me, the Tiger's #1 fan, in a trade .

I'd at least counter at $90.  Also check sold listings to see if there are any comparable 1/1s to see what the market is going with.  It's temping to jump on the first offer (I've been there) but patience usually wins in this situation

So I actually brought him up from 56. I countered with 95, then 90. I watch pawn stars so I am kind of an expert, lolz.. I have a little over a day left before I need to decide. Just seeing if you all thought the worth might be over the 99 I started at.

I'd run it as an auction with a starting price of $99.99. 

So what happened??

I caved for a sob story at $85.  but, used my best Rick Harrison impersonation by getting in touch with a buddy of mine (all of the trading card db) to bring him up from $56.  And $85 was way closer to my $100 asking price.  

Thanks for the advice guys.  

Dang ok, well it was a pretty good price i wouldnt mind pulling a few like that from some packs lol.