Marty Barnett Forum

There are two cards scanned for baseball player Marty Barnett, PID 72574. The 1998 and 1999 Reading Phillies. Are these the same person? Could someone check them out please. If different, who is who??

The 1999 card is not Marty Barnett. It looks like it could be Ryan Brannan.

UPDATE: it could be Marty if it's a 1999 photo.

Looks like he signed this card:

http://www.dailyautograph.com/2016/04/marty-barnett.html

So I would guess that the 1998 is the UER one. I seriously doubt he'd sign a card that didn't feature him, and that card companies would miss that badly twice.

The 1998 card looks correct, Marty Barnett wore #27 in 1998 (wasn't with team in 1997). In 1999 he wore #38. So the 1999 card could be Marty if it's a 1999 picture.  Or Ryan Brannan if it's a 1998 picture.

vrooomed wrote:

Looks like he signed this card:

http://www.dailyautograph.com/2016/04/marty-barnett.html

So I would guess that the 1998 is the UER one. I seriously doubt he'd sign a card that didn't feature him, and that card companies would miss that badly twice.