2017 Topps Baseball Forum

Jeff Kent.

Fred McGriff would also be a better choice.

My opinion on DH's in the HOF would reguire one of the following be achieved:

3000 Hits

500 Home Runs

2 MVP's

He missed on all three.

Again, just my opinion.

Lee Smith held that record for a long time. He played in Chicago, Boston, and L.A.

I also don't get the no-DH mindset. If a DH doesn't belong in because he doesn't field a position, then an American League pitcher doesn't belong in because he doesn't bat.

Lee Smith held that record before all saves were one inning. And he played on some baaad teams. (And some good ones. Don't forget St. Louis and Baltimore). He should be in. (Total Cubs bias here, though). 

No problem with a DH in the Hall. Gotta put up amazing numbers, though. On numbers alone, I wouldn't put Martinez in. But I give him a vote in a few years because he helped redefine the position (or lack thereof). 

I'll add Vlad, too. Just not yet. He's in the Dawson, Rice realm, along with Bagwell, and Kent. Not offended that they're (or would be) in. Would understand if they weren't. 

For David and v3, notice I have Smith on my list as well.  I believe he should already have been in.

The voters mind set about DH and relievers is dumb.  The designated hitter and the reliever are player roles and are part of the game.  Both play key roles in the outcome of many games. Therefore those players who fill those roles should be considered on how well they played in those roles. Edgar is probably the most reknown DH always hitting for a high average.  Smith and Hoffman were two of the best in the short relief / closer role.  All 3should be voted in. 

After all, we aren't talking bat boys here.