It's not baseball, but it's easily the best card I've ever pulled that I still have. From a single $3 pack of 2000 UD Ultimate Victory football, I pulled a Tom Brady RC SN2000. Not many people knew who he was then, but I kept it because I also collect the Patriots. That card is easily the card that I could sell for the most money (if I wanted to) from my entire collection. Even better is that it was one of several packs my Grandma gave me for Christmas that year. I also pulled a Brady RC from a Skybox Impact pack from that stack (still have it too).
For baseball, I have 2 cards that immediately come to mind. #1 is a 2009 UD Icons Immortal Lettermen Ozzie Smith patch SN40. Even though they are manufactured patches (not from a worn or used jersey), it was exactly the "hit" I was hoping to pull from that box. #2 came from the same box, NOT for what I pulled but for what I did with it. I pulled a Pablo Sandoval AU card that I quickly traded for a Mint Ozzie Smith 1979 Topps RC. I finally got my white whale of 25+ years in the condition I wanted without having to buy it!!!
I have a trio in NASCAR that really stand out. The one that is still in my personal collection is a 2016 Panini Certified Jimmie Johnson AU, SN15 card. It's the only JJ AU that I've ever pulled myself but the SN was 13/15 and (at the time) it became the 13th JJ AU in my collection (I have 22 JJ AU's now). Even at a highly discounted price of $35 for the box in 2018, the JJ was the only card that made that box worth the money! By value, my best pulls were cards that I quickly traded for goodies for my PC. My highest BV card ever pulled, at the time I pulled it, was a 2010 Press Pass Legends Quad-AU, SN25 card of the Force Family (NHRA's John Force and his 3 daughters). I traded that for my first ever JJ AU and a Mark Martin 2009 Press Pass Showcase SN5 Triple MEM card. A few years ago, I found a 2009 PP Showcase box for under $200 and bought it b/c it finally hit my price-mark for buying another box. From that box I pulled a Dale Earnhardt Sr. Jumbo Firesuit SN25 card. I traded that card and several others for a Jeff Gordon AU/MEM, SN45 from 2011 Showcase and a Danica Patrick AU/MEM, SN25 from 2010 Showcase. I still have both of those cards and the Martin card. I traded the 1st JJ AU/MEM card years later to someone trying to complete the set for a different JJ AU/MEM card. Then I traded that one to another set collector for a different JJ AU/MEM card. Each time I traded the JJ AU's, I got one a little older. You can read all about my JJ AU collection and the trades in the User List on my Profile page.
I've had some very awesome pulls in my life, but I've still never pulled a 1/1 card of any kind. I own a bunch, but have never pulled one myself. Most of the really good pulls I've had got traded for something I actually wanted and they usually went very fast.
NO PWE's EVER!!! PLZ PM me 1st before sending any offer. ONLY selling cards as of March 2024. No trades or purchases right now.
_______________________________________________________________________
Largest total PC card collections by Team, then Athlete (as of 3/22/24):
STL Cardinals (MLB) - 8810; Carolina Panthers - 2888; GB Packers - 1790+ cards
Mark Martin (NASCAR) - 2038 cards; Jimmie Johnson (NASCAR) - 1875 cards; Jeff Gordon (NASCAR) - 1594; Ricky Rudd (NASCAR) - 839; Ozzie Smith (MLB) - 707