Site Forum

The submissions are now closed and it is time for us to move into voting on your favorite 5 cards from each list. The lists are public and they will be listed below. Please vote for 5 cards in each list, no less, no more. You do not need to vote for every category. Leave a comment on each list for the cards you are voting for the numbers are just fine. This will be open for at least 2 weeks (mostly depending on life and if I can get to it after 2 weeks). The 5 categories to vote on are Baseball, Basketball, Football, Hockey, and Non-sport/misc sport (this includes gaming as well).

Next week the top 10 will be voted on and you will have a chance to vote on your favorite 3 cards in each list. Each card with 80% of votes will get into the TCDB HOF or the top 2 cards in each category if no cards are over 80 %. 

Note cards without scans did not get added to the list.

The five lists are

1. Baseball

2. Basketball

3. Football

4. Hockey

5. Non-sport/Misc sport

Baseball 

4, 12, 36,40, 42

i think vintage cards would be worthy of HOF. 

Please leave a comment on the list

Baseball

3, 12, 31, 41, 42

Hard to narrow this down 

Soccer is a main category and not under misc sports/non sports It is listed under  the soccer ⚽ tab and probably the largest sport in the 🌍🌎 world. We need to treat it better

Only 2 football (soccer) cards were submitted. You could have submitted more if you want it to have it's own category.

That Non-Sport/MISC Sport list was brutal. I agonized over my choices and still regret the votes I didn't make.  I mean honestly, the gaming cards are all legendary cards (all of them deserve a spot in HOF). I still can't wrap my head around not voting for Mike Tyson, Bart Simpson, MC Hammer, Spider-Man, Tony Hawk, Batman, or Pac-Man. Sheesh, can we have an ballot for that category alone?

I hear you, I am having the same problem with the baseball list for me.  The struggle of early hall of fame voters.  After a few years when the hall starts to fill up it will theoretically get easier as we look to add the few cards that deserve admission, but right now the choices are tough.

I did not expect for there to be only 2 soccer ⚽ cards submitted. If I would have known this I would have added 10 icon cards from the sport.

Baseball 40 27 19 18

basketball 3 5 12

Football 13 12 2 1

Hockey 20 28 27 16