Site Forum

I know this question has been discussed before, but I couldn't locate the thread so I thought best to ask again.  I recently bought a box of 2013 Panini Rookes & Stars Longevity football from my local shop.  As I researched the set, I learned it was a Target-exclusive release.  I prepared to upload checklists for the insert sets. When I pulled them from the Panini website, they didn't list separate, but as a type of parallel release under the Rookies & Stars base (?) release.  The inserts, Dress for Success, etc., are the same ones included in the standard 2013 Rookies & Stars (I hope I am explaining this okay).  My question is, should these inserts be included on the R&S Longevity set also, or just in the R&S, with a note to cross-reference? I really need some advice on this one.

I believe inserts should be listed with the products they were issued with. If that's more than one, so be it. Sometimes the same inserts are issued with more than product. For example some O-Pee-Chee and Topps hockey sets in the early 2000s issued the same Topps branded inserts in both products. Accordingly, the inserts are listed under both sets. The only difference in the listing for the OPC inserts are named "Topps ..." which isn't necessary for the Topps listing. 

the Rookie & Stars is one of my kryponite sets for me. on the earlier years there was a longeivtiy parallel and then there was another Longevitiy set - but the walmart/target issues should go within that set.

Thanks for the feedback on this.  I didn't want to upload a checklist without being sure.  

Here's a link to the previous discussion that I remeber on the topic:

CAN WE STANDARDIZE THE WAY WE ENTER SETS ISSUED IN MULTIPLE PRODUCTS?

It may not be entirely the same, but there are points made there that apply to this discussion.

-Tom

Thanks Lea!  That is the forum discussion I was looking for and couldn't find.  Reviewing, I should list the insert set under the R&S Longevity set, but name as R&S?